If you’re running an affiliate program but struggling to see consistent growth, you might be making one of these critical mistakes.
Many brands set up affiliate programs without a clear strategy—leading to wasted time, poor results, and missed revenue opportunities.
The good news? These mistakes are fixable.
In this post, we’ll break down the three biggest mistakes e-commerce brands make with their affiliate programs and show you how to fix them so you can scale profitably.
Let’s dive in.
Mistake #1: Not Prioritizing the Right Affiliates
Many brands launch their affiliate program without a clear recruitment strategy.
They assume that affiliates = influencers and content creators—but that’s just a small part of the affiliate ecosystem.
Instead of actively recruiting high-value affiliates, brands:
1. Accept anyone who applies—without vetting them.
2. Over-focus on social media influencers, ignoring other lucrative affiliate types.
3. Miss out on high-value media buyers, content sites, and industry-specific affiliates.
The Fix: Build a Clear Affiliate Profile
Before reaching out to affiliates, define who your ideal partners are.
Ask yourself:
1. Does Their Audience Match My Target Customers?
2. What Affiliate Types Work Best for My Brand?
3. Are They Already Promoting Similar Products?
Example Strategy:
Tier 1 Affiliates: Blogs & review sites ranking for competitor keywords.
Tier 2 Affiliates: High-engagement YouTubers, TikTokers, and Instagram creators.
Tier 3 Affiliates: Media buyers who run ads for commission-based payouts.
Actionable Step:
• Use Google search and SEO tools like SEMrush to find review sites ranking for your competitors.
• Build a hit list of these publishers and proactively recruit them.
Why It Works:
Review sites already generate high-intent traffic—they’re easier to onboard and drive immediate results.
Mistake #2: Offering Weak Incentives
Affiliate marketing is highly competitive.
Brands often fail to attract top affiliates because their commission rates are too low or their payout structure isn’t enticing.
1. Gone are the days when “we offer 10% commission” was enough to attract affiliates.
2. If your competitors are offering higher commissions, better perks, or exclusive bonuses—you will lose affiliates to them.
The Fix: Offer Competitive & Flexible Payouts
Step 1: Analyze Your Competitors’ Commissions
• Find out what top competitors are offering by checking their affiliate signup pages.
• If they offer 30% commissions and you offer 10%, you’re already at a disadvantage.
Step 2: Create Tiered Commission Structures
Example:
1. New Affiliates: 10% commission
2. High Performers ($10K+ revenue/month): 15% commission
3. VIP Affiliates ($50K+ revenue/month): 20% commission
Step 3: Offer More Than Just Money
Some top affiliates care about more than commission.
Consider offering:
1. Exclusive discount codes for their audience
2. Performance-based bonuses for hitting milestones
3. Priority access to new products
Why It Works:
Top affiliates care about earnings per click (EPC)—higher commissions + better conversion rates make them choose your brand over competitors.
Mistake #3: Poor Communication & Relationship Management
Many brands set up their affiliate program and forget about it—leading to:
1. Disengaged affiliates who stop promoting.
2. Missed optimization opportunities because no one provides updates.3. Lost revenue when affiliates switch to competitors with better support.
Affiliate marketing is relationship-driven—active communication keeps affiliates engaged.
The Fix: Treat Affiliates Like Partners
Step 1: Provide Regular Updates
Don’t wait for affiliates to ask for updates—keep them in the loop with:
1. Monthly newsletters highlighting new promotions & best-performing campaigns.
2. Exclusive insights (e.g., “This ad creative converted 20% better this month.”).
3. Pre-launch access to upcoming products.
Step 2: Schedule Check-Ins with Top Affiliates
For high-revenue affiliates, set up quarterly strategy calls to:
1. Understand their challenges.
2. Offer new campaign ideas.
3. Help them optimize their performance (and earn more).
Step 3: Build a Private Community for Affiliates
1. Create a Slack group or Discord server for affiliates.
2. Encourage them to share tips & insights.
3. Offer real-time support and build stronger relationships.
Why It Works:
Affiliates who feel supported and valued stay loyal—reducing churn and boosting long-term revenue.
Final Takeaways: How to Scale Your Affiliate Program Profitably
1. Focus on the right affiliates—target high-value partners instead of accepting random applications.
2. Offer competitive incentives—high commission rates, tiered structures, and exclusive bonuses.
3. Maintain strong relationships—keep affiliates engaged with regular updates and personalized support.
If you fix these three mistakes, you’ll see:
1. Higher-quality affiliates joining your program.
2. Increased revenue from better-performing partners.
3. Long-term growth instead of one-time affiliate spikes.
.webp)
Frederic Jean-Bart is a performance-based affiliate marketing expert with over 15 years of experience scaling multi-million dollar programs for some of the world’s top DTC brands. As the founder of Performance Partners, he has built a reputation as the go-to strategist for high-stakes affiliate deal-making—securing partnerships with the industry’s top-performing affiliates to drive explosive revenue growth.
Achieve profitable growth with a performance-based partner program
